Christmas Songs that Do Too Much

Twelve Christmas songs that always steal the limelight

by on

Christmas is nearly here, and the season often evokes scenes of quiet contentment. From the austere majesty of a silent, holy night overlooking flocks of sheep, to the postcard images of a resplendent tree gleaming in the light of a roaring fireplace, one face this holiday wears is serene, tender and mild. These scenes are often accompanied by carols picked out in harp-peggios1 or jazz instrumentals of classic holiday favourites that demurely form the backdrop to gatherings of friends and family.

Another group of Christmas songs aims to be the soundtrack to the party, mingling brightness and rhythm with predictability, so that all merry-makers may revel without being challenged extraordinarily. Whether you’re Rocking around the Christmas Tree or doing the Jingle-Bell Hop, you’re moving your feet over familiar territory! These songs are also perfect for settings like department stores and malls full of silver bells and candy canes.

And then, there’s a third class of Christmas songs. These are songs that refuse to fade into the background, but instead jump up and demand the spotlight. Whether it’s their emphatic high energy, dramatic key changes or mixing of genres and archetypes, something about these songs really brings the over-the-top energy. These are Christmas Songs that Do Too Much, and I have collected a list of 12 that have stood out to me over the past few holidays and that I think would make a grand addition to your holiday season.

Don’t let my tongue-in-cheek title dissuade you, for these are songs which I think are extremely well-executed. If you like Christmas or music or Christmas music, these songs will surely be interesting, if not a delight.

Have a suggestion that you think I’ve missed? Please reach out and let me know.

And last of all, I wish you a merry Christmas and a happy New Year!


  1. TIL that the word arpeggio comes from italian, “arpeggiare”, which literally means “to play the harp”. But since we can arpeggiate on any instrument today, I’m sticking with harp-peggio to suggest the instrument + the technique. ↩︎